When Nancy Lam upgraded in January to a home closer to her child’s school in the San Francisco Bay Area, she thought she had plenty of time to list her old house, a five-bedroom modern home in the sought-after suburb of Lafayette.
After all, the pandemic had sent the luxury housing market soaring, and homes across the country were seeing aggressive bidding wars and selling for sky-high prices. Ms. Lam, a business professor, and her husband, who works in healthcare and declined to be named, took their time sprucing up the house in a bid to get the best possible price for the home, which they had bought for $1.67 million in 2014.
But after listing it for $3.95 million in May, they realized they may have miscalculated. After weeks on the market, the house hadn’t been scooped up like they expected. There were no reasonable offers, and no bidding wars. Now, four months and two significant price cuts later, the property is still lingering on the market, asking $3.49 million.
“It’s crazy,” she said. “We never expected for this to still be on the market. It really caught us by surprise.”
Experts say stories like Ms. Lam’s are becoming increasingly common as the luxury housing market cools following its pandemic-induced bull run. A new report by real-estate brokerage
shows that in the three months ending Aug. 31, sales of luxury U.S. homes dropped 28.1%, from the same period last year. That marks the biggest decline since at least 2012, when Redfin’s records began, and eclipses even the 23.2% decrease recorded during the onslaught of the pandemic in 2020, the report said.
Sales of nonluxury homes also fell during the same period, but that drop—19.5%– was smaller than the decline in the luxury market, which is defined as the top 5% of homes based on estimated market value, according to Redfin.
“Six months ago, people were buying homes over-ask and with no appraisal,” said Ms. Lam’s real-estate agent, Herman Chan of Golden Gate Sotheby’s International Realty. “They didn’t even bat an eyelash. Now, it’s like crickets.”
High-end California markets have seen some of the steepest declines in sales volume, Redfin’s data shows. The number of home sales plunged by close to 64% in Oakland, Calif., while San Jose and San Diego also posted decreases of more than 55%. The number of home sales fell 44.3% in Los Angeles, 55.5% in Miami and 11.8% in New York.
Buyers are getting “sticker shock” when they see the impact of rising rates, which is causing them to re-examine their finances and their buying power, she said. And while superwealthy buyers often aren’t directly impacted by interest rates—many purchase in cash—Ms. Fairweather said they are still paying attention to wider economic indicators.
“We’re dealing with inflation, and inflation cuts into profits,” she said. “Rich people definitely care about how much profits the companies they are invested in are making. That affects stock prices, it affects treasury yields.”
As for purchasing real estate in all cash, Treasurys seem like a better bet than real estate right now, Ms. Fairweather said. “No investor wants to put their money into an asset that is going down in value,” she said.
Mr. Chan said he believes the slowdown in activity is more severe in the luxury market because high-end homeowners have a greater degree of discretion about when to sell and at what price. Often, sellers face no financial pressure to move, he said; they can just wait it out.
Scott Lennard, an agent with Compass in the Seattle, Wash., area, who is listing a $12.5 million estate on Lake Washington, said his client is willing to hold out for the right price and is in no rush to sell, though the property has been on the market for about eight months.
SHARE YOUR THOUGHTS
What is the state of the housing market in your area? Join the conversation below.
While the volume of luxury sales across the country has dipped dramatically, prices are still holding firm, though their growth has slowed. The median sale price of a U.S. luxury home grew 10.5% to $1.1 million during the three months ending Aug. 31, according to Redfin, compared with a 20.3% increase during the same period of last year. Ms. Fairweather said she expects prices to decline throughout the winter.
Meanwhile, many buyers no longer feel urgency to move quickly, because houses are sitting on the market longer, Mr. Chan said. Some of his clients also dropped their budgets amid stock market volatility this summer, he said. One couple was originally shopping for a home in the $5 million range, but reduced their budget to around $4 million after some of their stocks took a battering and interest rates rose, he said. “They basically lost their down payment buffer zone,” he said.
In Seattle, Mr. Lennard said he sees tech buyers pulling away from the market and taking a “wait and see” approach. The stock prices of
two major employers in the area, have fallen significantly in the last year, he said.
“That does certainly have an impact on the high-net worth buyers, because so much of their compensation is tied up in stock versus salary,” he said.
Other buyers have left the market during the pandemic frenzy. Frederick Oshay, 62, head of a packaging supplies company, said he planned to buy a home after relocating to the Montecito area from San Francisco’s East Bay last year. He and his agents, Adam McKaig and Melissa Borders of
looked at numerous homes priced between about $3.5 million and $7 million, and he even made offers on a few, but was outbid. Now, he said, he is taking a step back until prices start to come down.
“If something was really enticing, I’d probably jump back in,” he said, noting that he’s now seeing more inventory creep onto the market and a slower pace of sales. “But in terms of aggressively pursuing properties in what looks like a bubble, I would say it is time to exercise some buyer prudence.”
With the mid-2000s real estate crash in mind, Mr. Oshay said he is wary of buying at the top of the market.
“I know people who bought houses in 2007 and 2008 and then were like, ‘Oh my gosh, I wish I hadn’t bought.’” he said. “That trauma still has a little bit of impact. I don’t want to get crushed.”
The shortage of luxury inventory that helped drive prices at the start of the pandemic is easing, Redfin’s data shows. The number of luxury homes for sale nationwide is up 39.2% from a record low of roughly 121,000 earlier this year.
Many sellers, however, haven’t adjusted to the new realities of the market, Mr. Chan said. Some of his buyers have made lowball offers on homes, only to be met with significant resistance. “It’s a stalemate,” he said. “Sellers are living in the past, the buyers are living in the future.”
Shannon Hagan of Coldwell Banker Realty said she has also seen buyers starting to retreat from the luxury market in the greater San Diego area. Many are waiting for price cuts that so far haven’t materialized.
Shannon Hagan’s Carlsbad listing has been on the market since June.
The house is about 6,258 square feet.
An outdoor fire pit.
The home has ocean frontage.
“I see a lot of people sitting on the fence, waiting to see who is going to say ‘uncle’ or who’s motivated,” she said. “And most of the people that own those properties are not motivated.”
One of her listings, a $14.95 million oceanfront mansion in Carlsbad, Calif., has been on the market since June. While the seller received one verbal offer, a sale never materialized. Still, she said, her client is wealthy and isn’t desperate to sell. “They don’t have to ever sell—they can carry these properties in perpetuity,” she said.
Ms. Fairweather attributes declines in pricey California markets partly to the popularity of remote work. “People used to live in places like San Francisco because of its great job market,” she said. “But now you can take that job basically anywhere in the country.”
Mr. Chan said he has a number of San Francisco clients who have looked to leave the city in part because of the prevalence of homelessness in some areas.
Ms. Fairweather said she doesn’t see the luxury market improving soon, thanks to persistent inflation and the likelihood of further interest-rate hikes. She said it is likely to remain in “a holding pattern” until the economy starts to improve.
That’s bad news for sellers like Ms. Lam. While she said she’s grateful to have found a new house, she noted that it’s difficult to carry two mortgages and two sets of property taxes and insurance. “We didn’t budget to be carrying two of everything for more than a couple of months,” she said.
Write to Katherine Clarke at Katherine.Clarke@wsj.com
Copyright ©2022 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 87990cbe856818d5eddac44c7b1cdeb8